Skip to main content


Folks Who Answer Your Calls

Justine Preston

Accounts Receivable Specialist & Senior Account Representative



Andrea Woods

Logistics Supervisor

Shawn Sanders

Operations Manager



Michael serves as President and Chief Operating Officer. He is a native Floridian and began working in the equine industry at a young age. During this time, Michael gained invaluable hands-on experience on a local Thoroughbred farm in Williston, FL. In 2004, Michael started American Shavings LLC, and spent 10 years operating and developing the business until its sale to All-In Removal in 2014. Since the acquisition, Michael has served in many capacities including his most recent role as Head of Operations where he managed the All-In Removal’s Ocala transfer station – a massive covered staging area ensuring all shavings are kept dry. Michael’s wife Carley operates the Williston Country Market, a business they own together, and they have two children.
Michael Earnest

President & COO


Erin joined All-In Removal in February 2019 as the Assistant Controller and was promoted to Controller in January 2021. She obtained her Bachelor’s Degree in Accounting from Johnson & Whales University in Providence, Rhode Island and her Master’s Degree in Accounting from Southern New Hampshire University. Erin, her husband, Jed, and their daughter moved to Florida in July 2017 from Massachusetts. When Erin is not at work you can find her coaching their travel softball team, spending time with their dogs, or enjoying time on the water.
Erin Barth



James is the IT Manager and System Administrator at All-In Removal. His interest in cybersecurity, block-chain and cryptography applications, system administration, and user-experience/user-interface design ensures All-In Removal is running smoothly on the technological side. James studied Civil Engineering at the University of Florida and Information Technology at Daytona State College. Having an interest in growing technologies and a passion to implement tools effectively, James brings a well-balanced set of skills to All-In Removal, where he loves to assess the behind-the-scenes processes that allow the equestrian community to thrive. Growing up, James enjoyed visiting Belmont Park with his grandfather and Gulfstream Park with his uncle. Today in his spare time, James enjoys running, yoga, training his dog, and engaging in the hopeful optimism for future technologies.
James O’Hare

IT Manager and System Administrator


Kelsey joined All-In Removal in October of 2016 as an Accounting Assistant before obtaining her Bachelor's Degree in Organizational Management in December of 2016 from Santa Fe College in Gainesville, Florida. She started off at All-In Removal answering phones and reconciling credit cards. Today, Kelsey is in Human Resources where she works diligently towards providing a friendly, inclusive, and productive workplace environment which values, rewards, and retains its employees. Outside of work, Kelsey enjoys spending time with her big family and traveling.
Kelsey Whitehurst

Human Resources

Board of Directors


Reid is the chairman and majority owner of All-In Removal. Reid received his bachelor’s degree from Georgetown University and masters and doctoral degrees in political economy from Johns Hopkins University. Reid has a long career in building businesses. He was the vice chairman, chief financial and administrative officer of a large New Jersey savings bank and then worked in the financial services and arbitrage affiliates of Ivan F. Boesky and Co. He founded SNL Financial in 1987 -- a leading global sector specific purveyor of news, corporate, market, and financial information. SNL Financial was sold to Standard & Poors in 2015, at which time it had 3,300 employees working in 23 offices in 11 countries around the globe. Today, Reid owns a real estate business that operates two north central Florida equestrian facilities: Black Prong Equestrian Village, an equestrian RV park, and Big Lick Farm at Oak Ridge Training Center, a thoroughbred training center. Reid is also the founding limited partner of Endicott Growth Equity Partners and a member of the investment committee of Endicott’s general partner where he opines on its prospective investments in financial information businesses. Reid spends his time building businesses and assisting his wife, Sarah, training racehorses.
Reid Nagle



Sarah is a Thoroughbred horse trainer and exercise rider. She obtained her exercise rider’s license at Pimlico Race Course in Baltimore, MD, while in high school and continued her equestrian career during and after college. She received her Bachelor’s Degree in English and Psychology from the University of Virginia.
Sarah McCord Nagle



After starting her career in health care communications, Judy was hired by Reid Nagle in 1993 as Director of Marketing for SNL Financial in Charlottesville, VA. Later, Judy transitioned to Business Manager for Reid’s family and related business ventures. Since 2015, Judy has served as the Chief Financial Officer and Chief Administrative Officer before assuming the role of Chief Operating Officer at Big Lick LLC. Judy continues to manage and oversee all financial, insurance, risk, and compliance matters for all personal and business activities of Reid and his family. In this role, she has oversight of the financial activities for Big Lick LLC, All-In Removal LLC, and Black Prong Equestrian Village LLC in addition to the shared operational oversight with Reid. Judy also serves as Secretary, Treasurer, and member of the board for All-In Removal LLC.
Judy Lewis



Adam joined Big Lick LLC as its Chief Financial Officer in March 2020 and recently added CFO duties for All-In Removal, after spending 20 years in financial management roles for large, multi-national companies. An Arkansas native, Adam earned his Bachelor’s Degree in Accounting and MBA from the University of Central Arkansas and is a licensed CPA in the State of Arkansas. Adam enjoys anything active and outdoors as well as traveling. He currently resides in the Gainesville, FL area with his wife, Christin, and their three children.
Adam Lites

Director and Holding Company CFO

Got Questions?

Contact Us

  • Please enter a number from 10 to 20.
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Manure Removal and Shavings Delivery Call 352-529-0800